686 Smarty 3-in-1 Form Jacket – Men’s

We’ve read the reviews across the web for the 686 Smarty 3-in-1 Form Jacket – Men’s and summarize the results below:

Universal Ranking

PeakScore: 79 (out of 100)
User Rating: 4.7 stars 
Expert Rating: 2.3 stars

Number of Ratings Reviewed: 88

Pros & Cons

Reasons to buy:

User Reviews

  • High-quality material and construction for a long-lasting product.
  • Comfortable to wear all-day-long on the mountain.
  • Waterproofing works well in a variety of conditions for versatility.
  • The pant-to-jacket system is efficient and works well.
  • Does a great job at blocking the wind from entering and making the user cold.
  • Provides substantial warmth for a thinner jacket, although some users may wish the jacket was thicker to begin with.
  • The fit isn’t too baggy or too tight, or a functional fit.
  • Features a removable liner for temperature flexibility.
  • Features pit vents for added breathability during warm days.

Reasons NOT to buy:

User Reviews

  • Some reports of the hood being too small to fit over a helmet.
  • The liner is clingy to both wool and cotton, so it can be tedious to put on the jacket.
  • The sleeves are a little tight for climbing comfortably.
  • Some users found the jacket not as warm as they were hoping.
  • Some bigger-sized people may wish that the length was a bit longer.


The 686 Smarty 3-in-1 Form Jacket for men is a high-quality, waterproof, and comfortable jacket to wear all-day-long on the mountain. Despite not being as thick as some hoped and the material being a bit clingy, the jacket provides weather protection and warmth for a thinner jacket. Although many users like the fit, it might be too tight in the sleeves for climbing functionality.


Note: User and expert rankings were reviewed across the web. Some expert reviews include these: 1.