We’ve read the reviews across the web for the Black Diamond Guide Glove – Men’s and summarize the results below:
Universal Ranking
PeakScore: 78 (out of 100)
User Rating: 3.8 stars 
Expert Rating: 4.1 stars
Number of Ratings Reviewed: 156
Pros & Cons
Reasons to buy:
User Reviews
- Windproof and waterproof.
- Leather allows for a snug fit.
- Padded for comfort.
- Many reports of keeping hands warm in arctic temperatures.
- Leather palms for durability.
- Nose wipe material on thumbs.
- Wrist part extends up forearm and over a winter coat.
- Warm removal liner attached with velcro.
- Can waterproof the leather so it doesn’t wet-out.
- Gore-Tex membrane and PrimaLoft insulation creates warmth and waterproof barrier.
Expert Reviews
- Dries quickly due to removable liner.
- Stretchy shell reinforced with goat leather for durability.
- The wool on the back of the hand is cozy on cold days and provides wicking ability.
- Nylon shell for waterproofing.
- The palm reinforcement is stitched around the edges and at the center, creating more traction.
Reasons NOT to buy:
User Reviews
- Long break-in time due to stiffness.
- No thinner liner for warmer days.
- Pricey.
- Not extremely dexterous.
- Difficult to get the liner back in.
- May need to size-up so the fit isn’t too snug.
Expert Reviews
- Insulation makes it a bulkier glove.
- Very stiff at first, and can be uncomfortable for a few days.
- Durable, but the insulation slowly packs out.
Summary:
The Black Diamond Guide Glove for men is an ideal glove for those in arctic climates, people who get cold hands, and for mountaineering. The durability, warmth, removable liner, weather-resistance, and comfort make this a top-choice for harsh cold-climate use.