We’ve read the reviews across the web for the Shimano XT PD-M8020 Trail Pedal and summarize the results below:

Universal Ranking
PeakScore: 93 (out of 100)![]()
User Rating: 4.8 stars ![]()
Expert Rating: 4.2 stars ![]()
Number of Ratings Reviewed: 291
Pros & Cons
Reasons to buy:
User Reviews
- Adequate surface for support.
 - Easier to find the clips than the smaller platform version.
 - Easy to adjust the release tension.
 - Easy to slip foot in-and-out.
 - Easy to install and clean.
 - Easy to mount.
 - Lightweight.
 - Durable build.
 - Effective for beginners.
 - Cage is small enough that doesn’t add bulk.
 - Reasonably priced.
 
Expert Reviews
- The machined aluminum provides a consistent feeling of resistance on the shoe.
 - The distance between the end of the float and release is short and consistent.
 - The machined platform doesn’t feel more slippery when it’s damp.
 - Pedal feels safe and stable due to increased surface area.
 - Adjustable and serviceable bearing system
 - Tension is easily adjusted with a 3mm hex key.
 - Extra width helps to prevent foot roll when tilting the bike into corners
 
Reasons NOT to buy:
User Reviews
- Could be better at mud-clearing.
 
Expert Reviews
- Doesn’t have as smooth of a snap on the top end pedal.
 - Lack of adjustability due to no traction pins.
 - A bit heavier than the competitors.
 - The steel-bearing retainer and slim axle don’t allow for removal using a 15mm pedal wrench, but has less surface area for mud build-up.
 - Despite a bigger platform, this isn’t a pedal that you want to unclip from and attempt standing on.
 - SPD binding protrudes awkwardly, and any pedaling in a soft-soled shoe will become uncomfortable.
 
Summary:
The Shimano XT PD-M8020 Trail Pedal is for mountain bikers searching for a well designed easy-to-use pedal with a bigger platform. This is not the best choice for those who want to cycle with soft-soled shoes, but for mountain bikers who want high quality performance.
