Patagonia Dirt Craft Bike Short – Men’s

We’ve read the reviews across the web for the Patagonia Dirt Craft Bike Short – Men’s and summarize the results below:

Universal Ranking

PeakScore: 85 (out of 100)
User Rating: 4.4 stars 
Expert Rating: 3.8 stars

Number of Ratings Reviewed: 87

Pros & Cons

Reasons to buy:

User Reviews

  • Sturdy and lightweight.
  • The material does not bunch, enhancing mobility and comfort.
  • The stretchy fabric promotes flexibility.
  • Breathable material.
  • The waist band features micro-adjustments for determining the appropriate fit.
  • Pockets are placed efficiently and functionally.

Expert Reviews

  • The chamois is comfortable for long endurance-rides.
  • There are ample pockets for storage, with two unsecured pockets on the front, and one zippered-pocket on the left thigh.
  • The nylon straps include snap buttons for attaching the chamois to the shorts.
  • The DWR can help in preventing against light precipitation and mud spatter.
  • The shorts are bluesign approved, meaning they are sustainably-sourced.
  • The waist closure features an integrated and adjustable belt for comfort.

Reasons NOT to buy:

User Reviews

  • The liner can make the shorts feel a bit bulky for walking in.
  • Some reports of users wishing they sold the shorts without the liner.
  • Some reports of the waist fitting, but the rest of the fit being too tight.
  • Sliding the sizing clasps in and out of the loops can be tedious and difficult if wearing gloves.

Expert Reviews

  • The lack of articulation can slightly restrict mobility.
  • The seams are rough and can cause chaffing on longer rides.
  • The chamois pad is large, which can be comfortable for long-rides, but difficult for walking or hiking.
  • The cut is more similar to a hiking-short than to a performance-oriented mountain-biking short.
  • The stretch in the pants is 2-way, compared to 4-way, which includes both horizontal and vertical stretching.
  • The shorter inseam means there is less leg coverage, which may not be ideal for prolonged downhill use.
  • The leg cuffs can sometimes ride up above knee-pads.
  • The hook system for tightening the shorts can come unhooked sometimes.


The Patagonia Dirt Craft Bike Short for men is a functional piece that can be used for mountain biking, climbing, and hiking, if you get the sizing right. The durability and adjustability make this a functional short, while the limited mobility and the heavily-padded liner may make this unsuitable for some body types, and for some aerobic activities.


Note: User and expert rankings were reviewed across the web, including here: 1, 2, 3, 4.